Does the FCC see a double standard between human violence vs. anthropomorphic violence in kid cartoons?

AnimatedFan01

Active Member
Joined
Dec 31, 2020
Messages
237
Location
United States
I've always wondered if violence or intense slapstick gags in children's cartoons are only permitted to certain extents with talking animal/anthropomorphic characters in ways that the bar gets set low with human characters. While violence in today's cartoons for kids certainly isn't allowed to go to the lengths of Looney Tunes or Tom and Jerry anymore thanks to outraged parents causing watchdogs to maximize their censorship standards, there are still times where anthropomorphic characters in modern kid cartoons are subject to violent gags that would have fatal consequences in reality, yet aren't *too* out of line with what Boomers saw on T&J or LT. I think child characters would especially be subject to this double standard since laws protecting children make abuse towards them more serious than towards adults.

My question is, have we ever seen a human character (be them a kid or adult) be subject to the following gags:

-Being baked into certain foods
-Catching on fire
-Being diced or sliced in half
-Being skinned
-Blowing up and dissolving into ashes

If any of these have ever happened to humans in Western animation, then they would *have* to be from the pre-colorization/cel animation era, and certainly before Ren and Stimpy hit the airwaves. And they were most likely the subject of adult characters, since children (teenagers too since they're equally protected as minors, though prepubescents are especially vulnerable) are given extra protection under the FCC's censorship regulations. I've never seen any of the above gags happen on The Loud House for instance, but I've seen them several times on SpongeBob in both eras (pre- and post-2005).

Tell me, in modern kid cartoons where anthropomorphic characters coexist with humans, do you think there are some gags that would be perfectly acceptable when the animals are subject to them, but wouldn't see the light of day on national television if any of the humans, especially children, were subject to them?
 

Dr.Pepper

Moderator
Staff member
Moderator
Joined
Sep 10, 2006
Messages
19,446
Location
In A House
There was an episode of Dexter’s Lab where his hair caught on fire, which lead to the “My hair is on fire!” meme. Not quite the same, but there was an episode of Ed Edd n Eddy where Edd was hit by moldy cheese and disintegrated into ash.
 

Red Arrow

ça va nog wel
Joined
Oct 22, 2012
Messages
16,903
Location
Belgium
These double standards also apply in real life. What do think happens when a rottweiler meets a cat? Humans aren't allowed to do that.
 

Spotlight

Members online

Who's on Discord?

Latest profile posts

PF9
I wonder what cartoons Caitlin Clark likes
Xilam is one of my most favourite animation studios, I enjoy alot of their cartoons from Hubert and Takako, Oggy and the Cockroaches and Zig and Sharko. Xilam is a studio that has inspired many and has created endless classics that we enjoy.

What's your most fond memory of Xilam?
Given how Drew Barrymore's production company Flower Films has mainly made live action projects for older audiences, them producing the TV special Olive The Other Reindeer and the Netflix preschool show Princess Power are definitely quite unusual. It would certainly explain the humor of the latter.
According to TVInsider, MTV2 will premiere Sponge on the Run movie on Sat Jul 13 at 6pm
It's such a shame that the anime with the long-pink-haired girls like Hinagiku Katsura and Bocchi are never officially dubbed into English. What do you think?

Featured Posts

Top