Fone Bone
Matt Zimmer
Star Trek: Picard "Hide And Seek"
I had mixed feelings.
I thought the stuff with Picard and his mother was great. Patrick Stewart was amazing. And Seven's stuff was good too.
I think my problem started and ended at Jarrati trying to get the Borg Queen to embrace "A New Kind Of Collective". It was hoary and cheesy. And yeah, I know it was totally on-brand for Star Trek, and The Next Generation specifically. But that's the part of Star Trek I find dated and the part I don't believe in anymore. I was always sort of skeptical of that message deep down, but I wanted to believe it. Now it's not remotely credible or something I'm willing to shut my brain off for anymore. Last week I complimented the show for finding selling points in humanity I believed in. The idea of "A New Kind Of Collective" is just claptrap, and this show is usually better than that.
Seven tried out for Starfleet and was denied because she was a Borg? Wow, 24th Century Starfleet sucks.
I also should probably concede that even if I didn't dig this specific episode, nothing in it diminished my admiration for this season and this arc. This show is allowed an occasional dumb episode. Being infuriated when a great show gives you a bad episode is the unreasonable reaction in my mind. I can think the non-Picard stuff here is stupid. That doesn't change the fact that I love this season and this show. **1/2.
I had mixed feelings.
I thought the stuff with Picard and his mother was great. Patrick Stewart was amazing. And Seven's stuff was good too.
I think my problem started and ended at Jarrati trying to get the Borg Queen to embrace "A New Kind Of Collective". It was hoary and cheesy. And yeah, I know it was totally on-brand for Star Trek, and The Next Generation specifically. But that's the part of Star Trek I find dated and the part I don't believe in anymore. I was always sort of skeptical of that message deep down, but I wanted to believe it. Now it's not remotely credible or something I'm willing to shut my brain off for anymore. Last week I complimented the show for finding selling points in humanity I believed in. The idea of "A New Kind Of Collective" is just claptrap, and this show is usually better than that.
Seven tried out for Starfleet and was denied because she was a Borg? Wow, 24th Century Starfleet sucks.
I also should probably concede that even if I didn't dig this specific episode, nothing in it diminished my admiration for this season and this arc. This show is allowed an occasional dumb episode. Being infuriated when a great show gives you a bad episode is the unreasonable reaction in my mind. I can think the non-Picard stuff here is stupid. That doesn't change the fact that I love this season and this show. **1/2.